The Homeowner's Guide to Evaluating Roof Condition

The Homeowner's Guide to Evaluating Roof Condition
Your roof protects everything you own. Learning to spot early warning signs can save you thousands of dollars in repairs and prevent serious water damage to your home. This guide shows you exactly what to look for, from the ground to the attic, so you can make smart decisions about your roof's health.
Check the last page to learn about our HealthyRoof Maintenance Program.
JUMP →
How Long Should Your Roof Last?
In southern Indiana, architectural asphalt shingles typically last 17-25 years. This projection assumes there is one layer, and no major wind, hail, or debris damage.
Roof Condition - starts off with a gradual decline and has a sharp drop-off as granules fall off.
→ 17-25 Years
Expected lifespan under ideal conditions
Knowing your roof's expected life helps you plan for replacement and catch problems early.
Determining Your Roof's Age
Knowing your roof's age is crucial for predicting its remaining lifespan and planning for future maintenance or replacement. If you've just purchased a home or can't recall when your roof was last replaced, there are several effective methods to uncover this vital information.
Google Street View
Review historical imagery on Google Street View. This can reveal past renovations like roof replacements, by spotting visual evidence of new roof installations over different years.
Google Earth Imagery
Utilize Google Earth's satellite imagery from various dates. These high-level views help identify when major changes, such as a full roof replacement, occurred on your property.
Pipe Boot Timestamps
Inspect plumbing vent pipe boots on your roof for production dates. This stamp indicates when at least part of the roofing system was installed, offering a strong age indicator.
Local Building Permits
Check with your local building department for permits related to your address. Roof replacements often require permits, and these records typically include the project date.
Combining these methods helps accurately pinpoint your roof's age. This provides a valuable starting point for assessing its current condition and planning future needs.
The number "14" stamped on this pipe boot indicates it was manufactured in 2014. This strongly suggests the roof was installed in 2014 or 2015.
This image shows how the color of the roof changed which would indicate that the roof was replaced between 2012 & 2014. These images were pulled from Google Earth's Historical Imagery feature.
Top Reasons Your Roof Might Fail
Age and Material Degradation
All roofing materials have a limited lifespan. Constant exposure to elements like UV radiation and natural erosion causes shingles to break down and sealants to fail over time, making the roof more susceptible to damage.
Severe Weather Exposure
Severe weather like hailstorms, strong winds, and intense sunlight significantly contribute to roof failure. High winds can tear shingles, hail causes impact damage, and sun degrades materials, leading to cracking and reduced flexibility.
Improper Installation Practices
Many roof failures stem from improper installation, such as incorrect shingle fastening, inadequate flashing, or insufficient attic ventilation. Even high-quality materials will fail prematurely if not installed correctly according to manufacturer specifications and building codes.
Natural Roof Aging
Your roof constantly faces the elements, leading to gradual degradation. Understanding these common signs of aging is vital for proactive maintenance.
Pipe Boot Deterioration
Pipe boots, made of rubber or plastic, seal around vent pipes. UV exposure and temperature shifts make them brittle, cracking and allowing water to seep into your attic.
Asphalt Wear-Through
The protective asphalt layer in shingles wears thin, especially with high sun exposure. This exposes the fiberglass mat, making shingles vulnerable to tearing and moisture.
Shingle Adhesion Loss
Shingles bond together via a thermal seal strip. Over time, this adhesion weakens, causing shingles to lift, curl, or become dislodged and compromising protection.
Granule Loss
Ceramic granules protect asphalt shingles from UV. As they detach and wash away, the exposed asphalt deteriorates faster.
Shingle Cracking
Asphalt oils evaporate with age, causing shingles to dry out and stiffen. This brittleness leads to cracking, compromising the roof's integrity.
These signs indicate your roof is nearing its end. Regular inspections identify issues early, allowing time for repairs or replacement before minor problems escalate.
Deteriorated Pipe Boot - this area is one of the most common leak areas.
Granule loss & asphalt wear through.
Green - Granules (UV protection)
Blue - Top Asphalt Layer
Red - Fiberglass Core
Shingles are separating in a zipper pattern. This pattern typically indicates that the shingles have stiffened from aging/overheating. These shingles typically have also lost their adhesion and are susceptible to wind damage.
Weather and External Factors
Beyond natural aging, your roof faces constant assault from environmental elements. Understanding these common culprits helps homeowners identify potential issues early and take preventative measures.
Proper installation and timely maintenance are essential to mitigate these external factors. Addressing minor issues caused by weather can prevent costly repairs.
Bullet lodged into roof
Shingle blown off due to lost adhesion. Core issue likely overheating.
Hidden Dangers: Improper Roof Installation
Even high-quality roofing materials can fail prematurely if installed incorrectly. Professional installation ensures optimal performance, but shortcuts or inexperience often lead to significant roof issues. Identifying these common flaws protects your investment and prevents costly future repairs.
Every step, from decking to flashing, requires precision. Overlooking small details creates weak points, allowing water intrusion and accelerating material degradation. This ultimately shortens your roof's lifespan.
Hidden Dangers: Improper Roof Installation (continued)
Inadequate Attic Ventilation
Insufficient intake and exhaust ventilation traps hot, moist air in the attic. This accelerates shingle aging, promotes mold growth, and increases energy bills. It can also contribute to ice dam formation.
Shingles on Low Slope
Standard asphalt shingles require a specific slope for proper water runoff. Installing them on very low-slope sections leads to water pooling. This quickly penetrates shingle layers, causing leaks, as they are not designed for standing water.
Improper Decking
The roof deck is the foundation for your roofing system. Uneven decking, gaps, or damaged sheathing create an unstable surface. This causes shingles to buckle or fail prematurely, compromising the entire roof's integrity.
Incorrect Shingle Staggering
Shingles must be staggered correctly to offset seams, preventing a continuous vertical path for water. Incorrect staggering creates weak lines where water easily penetrates. This often leads to leaks directly into the home.
When evaluating your roof, look for these signs of poor installation. Addressing them early prevents minor issues from escalating into major structural damage and costly repairs.
Nail in the keyway (where two shingles meet). This exposed nail will slowly leak.
Nail placed too low on the shingle (shiner). It is rusted and is slowly leaking.
The racking installation pattern was common for 3-tab shingle installation but is incorrect for architectural shingles. Incorrect stagger pattern can lead to water infiltration and unsightly appearance.
What To Check - Ground
01
Look for Algae Staining
Blue-green streaks aren't always a performance problem. Algae feeds on shingle filler, not the asphalt. Choose copper-infused shingles when replacing to resist algae growth.
02
Check Roof Lines
A properly functioning roof should appear flat and even. Wavy lines or dips indicate problems. Standing water is a serious issue that needs immediate attention.
03
Spot Missing Shingles
Underlayment only protects for weeks, not months. Missing shingles mean your roof is vulnerable to water damage right now.
04
Look for Shiny Edges
Shiny shingle edges indicate exposed fiberglass matting—a sign of advanced aging. This deterioration often starts at the edges and spreads inward.
05
Check Downspouts
Granules at downspouts are an early warning sign. Once granules are lost, deterioration speeds up because UV light hits the asphalt directly.
06
Compare All Slopes
Different sides age at different rates depending on sun exposure.
Granules can be seen in the gutters and indicates that the roof could now be classified as "towards end of life". Once the granules fall off there's a rapid degradation of the asphalt over the next several years.
"At End of Life" roof with heavy granule loss and the top asphalt layer worn through. The shiny shingles show the exposed center fiberglass core layer. This roof is at risk of water being able to soak through the shingles.
What to Check - Ladder & Roof
Ladder Inspection
Getting close to the edge reveals important details you can't see from the ground.
Granules in gutters
Look for granules in the gutters & at the bottom of the downspouts.
Number of Layers
Multiple layers visible. Multiple layers have a shorter lifespan.
Granule coverage
Check all surfaces for wear
Exposed fiberglass core
Late-stage deterioration visible
Shingle offset pattern
Look for irregular stagger
Inspect every slope
Check every slope
Roof Surface Inspection
Walking on the roof can reveal structural and surface issues. Listen and feel for problems.
Cracking sounds or soft spots could indicated back decking 
Granule loss or exposed fiberglass
Foot-traffic damage from previous work
Flaking or brittle asphalt
Overheated shingles (hard with sunken granules)
Loose or curling shingles
Step flashing and counterflashing present
Exposed nails anywhere
Dead valleys that hold water
Debris accumulation in valleys
Nail placed too high on the shingle and too close to keyway. This will lead to a slow interior leak.
This roof shows an incorrect stagger pattern. Overheated shingles have stiffened and begun to separate commonly indicating a loss of adhesion.
Multiple layers can be counted on the rakes (gables).
What You Can Check From the Attic
Spaced Decking
Boards with gaps between them cause shingle cupping and unpredictable leaks. Modern roofs need solid decking for proper support. Spaced 1×12 decking was a practice common in the 70's and 80's.
Water Stains
Look for dark stains on the underside of the decking. These subtle marks indicate current or past leaks that need investigation.
Sap Bleeding
Oozing sap in the framing lumber indicates excessive attic heat. This suggests a ventilation system issue and leads to accelerated shingle aging.
Exhaust Fans
Attic exhaust fan motors often fail around 12 years which impact attic moisture & temperature levels.
Mold Growth
Mold on wood surfaces points to moisture problems. Causes include roof leaks, poor ventilation, or improperly vented exhaust fans.
Blocked Airflow
Insulation against the roof deck obstructs soffit-to-attic airflow. Ensure clear channels for air movement from soffit to ridge vents.
This sheathing (wood decking) is not solid. Shingle manufacturers will NOT warranty their product when installed on this substrate, making proper support crucial.
When in Doubt, Get a Complete Inspection
Important: Many roof issues cannot be fully diagnosed from just one location. A proper evaluation includes ground-level, ladder, roof-surface, and attic inspections working together.
Each inspection location reveals different problems:
From the ground: Spot missing shingles and assess overall condition.
From a ladder: Observe granule loss and detect multiple layers.
On the roof surface: Feel soft decking and find hidden damage.
In the attic: Discover leaks and ventilation problems.
If you're not comfortable performing these inspections yourself, hire a qualified roofing professional. A thorough inspection costs far less than emergency repairs from water damage. Look for contractors who check all four areas and provide detailed reports with photos.
Understanding what to look for helps you maintain your roof properly and avoid expensive surprises. Regular inspections catch small problems before they become big ones. Your roof protects your most valuable investment—give it the attention it deserves.
HealthyRoof Maintenance Program
Our HealthyRoof Maintenance Program helps identify issues before they start to leak. It also determines the remaining lifespan of your roof, preventing costly surprises.
To learn more, text "HealthyRoof" or call 812-461-1887 to inquire about this program.